Icebox Cake


If you like custard or cream desserts, you will love this Icebox Cake.  This was my father’s favorite dessert.  Mom would make it for him every year for his birthday instead of a traditional cake.  There are similar desserts out there that use sweet crackers and pudding in a layered dessert, but this one is brought to the highest level.  Mom always made her own cream, never a boxed pudding, and she topped the cake off with a meringue made from the left over egg whites.  I use instead a home-made whipped cream topping because I like it better, but feel free to make the meringue.  Everyone that I have  served this to has loved it.  Give it a try…I’m sure you will like it too.

Ingredients for the cream:

5 – cups whole milk
1 – cup sugar
3 – heaping tbls. cornstarch
6 – egg yolks (well beaten)
1 1/2 – tsp. pure vanilla extract

Other ingredients:

3 – bananas 
30 – whole graham crackers (you will need more than one box)

Directions to make the pastry cream:

In a large sauce pan, add 4 cups of whole milk and 1/2 cup sugar.  Heat the mixture over a medium flame until it is dissolved.  Stir often to avoid burning the milk.

In the meantime, mix together in a bowl, the rest of the sugar, cornstarch, and the remaining cup of milk.  Mix until the sugar and cornstarch are dissolved.

In another bowl, separate the yolks from the egg whites and add the vanilla to the yolks.  With a fork whisk the yolks until smooth and add them to the cold milk mixture.  Blend the yolk mixture slowly into the hot milk mixture. Drizzle a little at a time into the hot milk while stirring constantly.  Do this slowly so that the eggs do not curdle.

Cook the cream on a medium-low flame, stirring constantly until thickened about 15-20 minutes.  Toward the end of the cook time, the cream will start to form bubbles on the surface, indicating that it is starting to come to a boil.  Check the flame and lower just a little to keep it at a simmer.  The bubbles are a sign that the cream is almost ready.  The consistency of the cream is a little loose, but do not let this worry you.  It will thicken in the refrigerator.


Assemble the cake:

In an 8″ x 12″ glass baking pan place a layer of graham crackers. graham-cracker-layerUse a ladle to pour about one cup of cream on top of the crackers, and spread evenly. Next add a layer of thinly sliced bananas.


Repeat the layers two more times then top off with a layer of graham crackers.  This pan will accommodate three layers of cream/bananas with final graham cracker top.

Now its time to make the whipped cream.

Ingredients for whipped cream:

1 – pint whipping cream
2 – tbls. powered sugar
1 1/2 – tsp. pure vanilla extract


Pour the cold cream into a mixing bowl.  Add the powdered sugar and vanilla.  Use a mixer on high and whip the cream until it is thick enough to make peaks in the cream and remain on the beaters without falling off.  This doesn’t take long, so be careful not to over whip the cream because it will curdle.



Spread the whipped cream over the top layer of graham crackers. Cover with plastic wrap and place in the refrigerator to chill for about 6 hours before serving.  You can leave it overnight if you have to.

Just before serving, take on graham cracker and crumble it.  Sprinkle the crumbs over the top of the cake.  Enjoy!

Servings:  12



Leave a Reply